Evaluating The Sermon: Ten Elements To Consider After You Preach
By R. Clifford Jones
Before
preachers soar homiletically, they must dig exegetically. Before we decide what
God wants to say through us to our congregations, we must know what He wanted
the biblical writer to say to another people in another place and time. And
we preachers must accept that biblical exegesis is not determining what the
biblical writer wanted to say, but discovering what the biblical writer wanted
to say. As such, the biblical exegete will go the Scripture with no preconceived
thoughts or personal agendas, but with an open mind, anxious to discover what
God has disclosed. In exegesis, the preacher strives for accuracy.
Some
preachers bunch or lump their exegesis together at the beginning of the sermon,
especially their discoveries relating to historical data. They feel it is crucial
to give all their background material first, to "lay the foundation,"
as it were. Exegesis works best, though, when it is interwoven throughout the
sermon and is undetectable, though evident. Exegesis should function in a sermon
as yeast does in bread or seasoning in food. It should impact the product but
not be glaringly detectable. And the preacher must ever resist the temptation
to impress the hearer with his or her scholarship, remembering that it is virtually
impossible to lift up Jesus and show oneself to be smart simultaneously.
Advertisement

Was
the sermon theologically sound? Preaching is a deeply theological act in which
a human being speaks a word on behalf of God. It is because God has spoken that
the preacher dares to speak, and the word the preacher proclaims must ring with
theology.
No
matter the passage of Scripture, the preacher must not only craft an exegetical
proposition, but a theological one as well. He or she must plumb for the profound
theological themes in the passage, linking them to similar themes in the rest
of Bible. Indeed, it is in comparing a theological principle or theme in one
pericope to a similar theme in another passage that the biblical exegete will
be able to test the veracity of that particular theme. Along the way, the preacher
will ask questions such as: "What is God saying and demonstrating to His
people in this passage? Was the sermon christocentric?"
It
is alleged that Charles Spurgeon once remarked that it didn't matter what his
passage for the day was, after reading it he would immediately make a beeline
to the cross. For Spurgeon, Christ and His cross were to be at once the core,
content and center of all preaching. Preaching that failed to lift up Jesus
Christ had no currency for Spurgeon, who like Paul reveled in the "foolishness
of the cross."
A
sermon that is grounded in the love of Christ will exhibit a grace orientation
even if it deals with matters of the law. It will reek of restoration and resurrection,
since, in a true sense, all Christian preaching is resurrection preaching. Hope
will not be a lacking ingredient, but an ever present reality that seasons every
element of the sermon.