This is the kind of thing that keeps Job off the motivational speaker circuit. I can guarantee you that Anthony Robbins or Charlie "Tremendous" Jones never say, "When your life is hard and torn, just curse the day when you were born."
Job goes on to request that that particular day be removed from the calendar. He requests "May those who curse days curse that day." (He doesn't tell us who "those who curse days" are; it seems like a limited profession.) For the next twenty-eight chapters Job pours out a level of bitterness, confusion, sorrow, and anger toward God that is staggering. He wants to know why God has forsaken him.
This is so raw that his friends can't stand it.
Advertisement
The Doctrine of Retribution
Job's friends spend twenty-two chapters voicing one central idea that was actually the primary theology of their day. It was written about in Mesopotamian wisdom literature. It is sometimes called "the doctrine of retribution." The idea is that goodness results in prosperity and blessing, wickedness results in suffering. Ironically, in their silence these friends drew Job closer to God. When they spoke, they pushed him away:
So Job, if you're suffering badly — you must have brought it on yourself. If you're no longer close to God-who do you think moved? If you will repent, he will deliver you from suffering.
Philip Yancey notes that the arguments voiced by Job's friends are being repeated in Christian churches today. Suffering people have told Yancey that those who make their suffering worse are Christians:
• "The reason you're in the hospital is spiritual warfare. If you were just engaging in spiritual warfare, Satan would be defeated and you'd be delivered."
• "God promises to heal — if we have enough faith. If you just had enough faith — just prayed boldly enough — you'd be healed."
We generally associate well-being with the presence of God and assume that suffering means someone has done something wrong. No one writes a book called Where Is God When It Feels Good? No one wins the lottery and cries out, "Why me, God?" And of course, it is true that pain was not part of God's original plan, and the day is coming when he will wipe every tear from every eye.
And yet . . .
While God hates pain, he can also redeem it. It does not mean he is absent. Years ago I helped conduct a survey that asked thousands of people what had most contributed to their spiritual growth. The number one answer was pain.
In summer I am tempted to think that because of my success, wealth, reputation, virtue, faith, I'm in control. My life will unfold how and when I want it to. In winter I learn I'm not running things after all. Somebody once said that the biggest difference between you and God is that God doesn't think he's you. In pain, we get very clear about not being God.
